Centre-state relations, with particular reference to the Sarkaria Commission report

proceedings of a seminar organised by the Leslie Sawhny Programme, Jaipur, August 5 to 7, 1988.

Publisher: The Programme in [Bombay]

Written in English
Published: Pages: 71 Downloads: 737
Share This

Places:

  • India
  • Subjects:

    • India. Commission on Centre-State Relations -- Congresses.,
    • Federal government -- India -- Congresses.
    • Edition Notes

      Other titlesCentre vs. state, can"t both be strong?
      ContributionsLeslie Sawhny Programme of Training for Democracy.
      Classifications
      LC ClassificationsJQ220.S8 C433 1988
      The Physical Object
      Pagination71 p. :
      Number of Pages71
      ID Numbers
      Open LibraryOL1686145M
      LC Control Number91907950

  Sarkaria commission Report- With a view to reviewing the working of the existing arrangements between the Union and the States in the changed socio-economic scenario, the Government constituted a Commission vide Ministry of Home Affairs Notification No. IV//1/CSR dated June 9, under the Chairmanship of Justice R.S. Sarkaria with. This article provides an overview and analysis of the Sarkaria Commission Report, the most prominent in a series of studies on Indian centre‐state relations. The article stresses the context under which the Sarkaria Commission was constituted and the reactions to it once released.   The terms of reference for the Punchhi Commission on Centre-State relations (), inter-alia, include the issues of sharing inter-State rivers and implementation of the river linking project. Sarkaria Commission submitted its recommendation report to Central Government with suggestions for various reforms in the administration and governance system. Most such recommendation reports were prepared after thorough assessment of various aspects for which the Commission conducted multiple studies and obtained various types of information.

The Council in its first meeting held on Octo had considered the recommendations made by the Sarkaria Commission on Centre—State Relations. Keeping in view the complexities of the Issues involved and their wider implications, it was decided by the Council that the recommenda­tions would be first examined by a Sub—committee of. The Commission after conducting several studies, eliciting information, holding discussions and after detailed deliberations submitted its report in January, UMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE COMMISSION ON CENTRE-STATE RELATIONS Para No. Recommendation in the Report. LEGISLATIVE RELATIONS. 1.   The Punchhi Commission is of the view that the Central Government should adopt strict guidelines as recommended in the Sarkaria report and follow its mandate in letter and spirit lest appointments to the high Constitutional office should become a constant irritant in Centre-State relations and sometimes embarrassment to the Government itself. It had total recommendations known as Sarkaria Commission. However some of the important recommendations were not implemented in the consequent years and a new commission on federal relations was constituted and it was known as Punchhi Commission, which submitted its report with more than recommendations.

Commission on centre state relations report (Vol. II). New Delhi, India: Constitutional Governance and the Management of Centre-State Relations. Google Scholar.   The Sarkaria Commission[27] justified the present position in the following words as: “The need for empowering Parliament to place restrictions on trade and commerce even within a State is obvious. Ours is a vast country with varying economic potentiality and considerable differences in regard to existing levels of development. The Commission submitted its report to the government in April In finalising the 1, page report, in seven volumes, the Commission took extensive help from the Sarkaria Commission report, the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC) report and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission report. Federalism refers to a politicalsystem that possess constitutionallyprovided and guaranteed distribution ofpowers between a national governmentand several regional governments. Themere existence of regional governmentsdoes not mean that the system followsfederalism. The fundamental attribute ofa federal constitution is.

Centre-state relations, with particular reference to the Sarkaria Commission report Download PDF EPUB FB2

Get this from a library. Centre-state relations, with particular reference to the Sarkaria Commission report: Centre-state relations of a seminar organised by the Leslie Sawhny Programme, Jaipur, August 5 to 7, [Leslie Sawhny Programme of Training for Democracy.;]. Research dossiers were culled and relevant data collected from various publications, including proceedings of public seminars, debates and reports of former Commission, Committees, Studies, decisions of the Supreme Court and High Courts having a bearing on any aspect of Union-State relations.

Commission; Sarkaria Commissions; Report of the Sarkaria Commission; Report of the Sarkaria Commission. Chapter 0. Introduction [Size kb] Chapter I. Perspective [Size kb] Chapter II.

Legislative Relations [Size kb] Chapter III. Administrative Relations [Size kb] Chapter IV. Role of the Governor [Size kb]. Download Sarkaria Commission’s Complete Report PDF on Centre(Union)-State Relations. Sarkaria With particular reference to the Sarkaria Commission report book was set up in June by the Government of India.

The Sarkaria Commission’s terms of reference was to examine the relationship and balance of power between state and central governments in the country and suggest changes within the framework of Constitution of.

since the Sarkaria Commission had last looked at the issue of Centre-State relations over two decades ago. In fulfilment of that pledge, Gazette Notification was issued on indicating Government’s resolve to set up the Commission including the terms of reference of the Commission.

Implementation Report on the decisions taken by Inter-State Council on the recommendations of Sarkaria Commission Of the recommendations of Sarkaria Commission on which final view has been taken by the Council, recommendations have been accepted and implemented, 65 recommendations have not been accepted either by the ISC or the.

Sarkaria Commission Report: In view of the various problems which impeded the growth of healthy relations between the Centre and the States, the Central Government set up a Commission in Juneunder the Chairmanship of Justice R.S. Sarkaria mainly to suggest reforms for an equitable distribution of powers between the Union and the States.

Sarkaria Commission(June ) which was a three member commission set up the central government under the Chairmanship of Retired Justice of Supreme Court Mr. Rajinder Singh Sarkaria to study, assess and recommend modifications with respect to the prevailing arrangements between the Central Government and the State Government.

Report of the Commission on Centre-State Relations An Appraisal of the Existing Framework of Centre-State Relations The Constitutional scheme of governance at the Centre and in the States is provided in Part XI (Articles to ), and Part XII (Articles to ), with few. So the Sarkaria Commission was an important attempt to streamline the centre-state relations.

It has become a reference point for any discussion on centre-state relations and it has been frequently referred to even by the judiciary. On its recommendation, the Inter-State council was established in and it has considered its recommendations. The commission on Centre-State relations, headed by Justice R.S.

Sarkaria, noted in its report, submitted inthe deep resentment that the abuse of this provision caused among the States. The States were treated under the Constitution with.

Inthe Central government appointed a three-member Commission on Centre–state relations under the chairmanship of R S Sarkaria, a retired judge of the Supreme Court The commission was asked to examine and review the working of existing arrangements between the Centre and states in all spheres and recommend appropriate changes and.

Sarkaria Commission was set up in by the central government of Sarkaria Commission's charter was to examine the central-state relationship on various portfolios and suggest changes within the framework of Constitution of India. The Commission was so named as it was headed by Justice Ranjit Singh Sarkaria (Chairman of the commission), a retired judge of the Supreme.

In keeping with the recommendations of the Sarkaria Commission Report, the United Front Government in its common minimum programme aimed at restoring a balance in the economic equation between the Centre and the States and bestowing greater autonomy on the latter in order that they are enabled to determine their needs and priorities independently.

The evolution of Centre State Relations can be classified into 4 different phases, with the first phase beginning in for a span of 17 years and finally culminating with the fourth phase beginning from Government of India had appointed Sarkaria Commission in to reduce the conflicts between the Central Government and State Governments.

The First Meeting of the Inter-State Council was held on to discuss the mainly agenda items on report of the Sarkaria Commission on Centre-State Relations.

The Tenth Meeting of the Inter-State Council held on discussed the agenda items on Atrocities on Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and status of implementation of the. The Sarkaria Commission on Centre-State Relations () was set up to examine the working of the arrangements between the Centre and the States and recommend such changes in the said arrangements as may be appropriate within the present constitutional framework.

In the proclamation of the emergency in the State, the report of the Governor about the functioning of the constitutional machinery of the State plays an important role as Article (1) provides that, “if the President on the receipt of report from the Governor of a State or otherwise, is satisfied that a situation has arisen in which the government of the State cannot be carried on in.

The Second commission on Centre-State Relations was set-up by the Government of India in April under the Chairmanship of Madan Mohan Punchhi, former Chief Justice of India It was required to look into the issues of Centre-State relations keeping in view the sea-changes that have taken place in the polity and economy of India since the Sarkaria Commission had last looked at the.

Recommendations of the Sarkaria Commission. A commission was appointed on Centre-state relations by Union government in It was headed by R. Sarkaria. It recommended - 1. Inter-State Council (Inter-Governmental Council) should be set up under Article 2.

The zonal councils should be constituted again. Essays on Development Strategy, Regional Disparities and Centre State Financial Relations in India: Papers on Development Strategy, Regional Disparities in Development and Centre-State Financial Relations in India (Hardback) by Hanumantha Rao and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at   A comprehensive review of Centre-State Relations was undertaken by the Sarkaria Commission in the mid-eighties.

In the two decades that have gone by both the polity and economy have undergone profound changes, posing new challenges for government at all levels and calling for a fresh look at the relative roles and responsibilities of each level.

Observations in the light of the report of the Commission on Centre-State Relations headed by R.S. Sarkaria, b.a former judge of the Supreme Court of India. Description: xiii, pages ; 22 cm: Responsibility: H.A.

Gani. Centre-state relations –ARsC –Chaired by later Hanumanthayya, constituted study team under MC Setalvad, 22 recommendations Establishment of Inter-State council Non-partisan governor Delegation of power to states More financial resources to states Deployment of central forces on request of state or otherwise.

The Sarkaria Commission on Centre–State Relations (–87) observed: The rule of federal supremacy is a technique to avoid absurdity, resolve conflict and ensure harmony between the Union and state laws. If this principle of union supremacy is excluded, it is not difficult to imagine its deleterious results.

The relations between centre and state are divides as: 1. Legislative relations 2. Administrative relations 3. Financial relations 1. Centre State Legislative Relations Articles to in Part XI of the Constitution deal with the legislative relations between the Centre and the State.

Extent of laws made by Parliament and by the. The fracas over the Terms of Reference (TOR) of the Fifteenth Finance Commission (FFC) highlights important tensions in Centre-state relations today. Following the decision to have a nominated Governor, references in the various articles of the Draft Constitution relating to the exercise of specified functions by the Governor 'in his discretion' were deleted.

(Chapter IV "Role of the Governor", Report of the Sarkaria Commission on Centre-State Relations () at para ). Sarkaria Commission. Justice R. Sarkaria presented the report of the commission on Centre-state relations, headed by him, to the Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, in New Delhi on Octo There have been many flash points in Centre-state relations over the years, including the reference to the 15th Finance Commission to adopt population as the base for devolution of funds to states.

The CPM wants a review on the role of the governor and relevance of the post. The demand that the governor should be appointed from a list of three eminent persons suggested by the chief minister, the criteria mentioned by the Sarkaria Commission, has gone totally unheeded, it said.Recommendations of the Sarkaria Commission.

A commission was appointed on Centre-state relations by Union government in It was headed by R. S. Sarkaria. It recommended - 1. Inter-State Council (Inter-Governmental Council) should be set up under Article 2.

The zonal councils should be constituted again. 3.Various important and well-intentioned attempts were made both to understand the role of the governor in our federal democratic set up and to recommend ways to make this institution conducive to strengthening center-state relations; for instance, the Administrative Reforms Commission ofthe Rajamanar Committee ofCommittee of.